Categories: , , , , , , , , , ,

Hi, this is Daniel Garber at the Movies for culturalmining.com and CIUT 89.5 FM.

Fall Film Festival season continues in Toronto with great new movies you can’t see anywhere else. The Female Eye Film Fest is on now, showing features and shorts by women, along with experimental, sci-fi and fantasy flicks and live talks with filmmakers. Reel Asian celebrates it’s 30th year, in theatres and digitally continuing till the end of the month. It’s featuring films like Ba’s Book, a personal doc about one family’s journey from Vietnam to Canada… via Iran.

But this week I’m looking at three new dramas about men encountering monumental opponents. We’ve got an actor in 1980s London dealing with AIDS, a father in 1980s Queens,  facing the Russian mob, and a young man in some future world, confronting an oppressive system.

Elsinore

Dir:  Simon Stone

It’s 1989 in London, with the AIDS epidemic killing scores of young gay men daily. Actor Ian Charleson (Andrew Scott: Pressure, Denial, All of us Strangers, Handsome Devil, ) is a noted leading man still riding the wave of Chariots of Fire’s big Oscar win almost a decade earlier. He’s still getting movie roles, though not of the same calibre; a trained Shakespearean actor he’s forced to take roles in low-budget action flicks. So he jumps at the chance to play Hamlet at the National Theatre, under the same director he’d worked with in a Guys and Dolls revival. This was what he’s always been hoping for. But alongside that fantastic offer came a bad omen: a little brown spot that appeared on his temple. It’s Kaposi Sarcoma. His friend, queer filmmaker Derek Jarman, calls it the “polka dot” stage. And Ian is HIV positive, a fact, along with his sexuality, he keeps completely hidden from a punitive society. Openly gay men don’t get work in movies.  

Only his closest circle knows about his illness: his sister Patsy, a casting director (Billie Piper), his ex-lover George (Luke Thompson), and a younger friend Sean (Matthew Beard). He is referred to Dr Margaret Johnson (Olivia Colman:Wicker, The Roses, Wicked little Letters, Empire of Light, Mothering Sunday, The Lost Daughter, The Favourite) a strict but effective physician trying out new HIV treatments at her clinic. But there’s the rub: her daily medical routines clash with his need to perform the physically taxing role of Hamlet at the National Theatre. In her eyes he should be resting to prolong his life, rather than wearing it out. Will this role be his swan song?

Elsinore is a dramatic biopic about an actor putting on a play during his the AIDS crisis. It deals with struggle, grief, and personal triumph. At the same time, it’s also a showcase for actor Andrew Scott’s talent and versatility both as the dying Ian and in sort of a “Hamlet’s greatest hits” including sword fights and all the famous soliloquies. What it doesn’t really convey is the awful government response to the AIDS crisis and the deep and widespread loathing, fear and oppression toward people with HIV at the time. What I did like was the dark humour of the script, the theatrical subculture — everything’s “darling, darling” — and the incredible detail behind the scenes at the National Theatre. That felt dead-on. And of course Andrew Scott is amazing.

Despite my misgivings, I found Elsinore a deeply moving and satisfying tear-jerker.

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping 

Dir: Francis Lawrence

Haymitch (Joseph Zada) is a young man who lives in a shack and supports himself doing odd jobs. He’s deeply in love with a woman who lives over the hill, where they plan a wonderful future together. They live in district 12 of Panem, the autocratic country divided into 12 oppressed areas all ruled by a wealthy capital city. Each year, as a sort of a punishment, a lottery chooses a young man and woman from each district to fight to the death in a cruel contest known as the Hunger Games. This year, on its 50th anniversary, they’ve doubled the tributes, including defenceless little kids. Only one tribute will survive. And the whole thing will be broadcast, like the ultimate reality show, with elaborate costumes, rituals and extreme violence. Viewers are encouraged to support their favourites. And though he was not chosen in the lottery, Haymitch is wrenched from his lover’s arms and sent to the capital along with three others from his district: the bougie Maysilee (Mckenna Grace), the cynical son of a bookie, Wyatt, and a frightened little girl named Louella, whom Haymitch vows to protect. But when she is accidentally killed due to negligence at an event before the games and replaced by a drugged-out lookalike, he expresses his anger on camera in an act of protest, thus earning him the enmity of the dictator himself, President Snow (Ralph Fiennes).

The tributes are feted and trained before the games, and Haymitch encounters a number of personalities; sycophantic bureaucrats, self-centred celebrities, vicious opponents trained since birth to win these games, and eccentric scientists secretly plotting to overthrow the governmenl. But how long will Haymitch survive the Hunger Games?

Solstice. Photo Credit: Murray Close

Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is a prequel to the famous YA series. It’s exciting with dazzling special effects. But a bit hard to follow: I read all three Hunger Games books, and saw all the movies, but even I had trouble remembering who’s who, with the barrage of name and faces from the past but played by different actors at different ages (this one takes place 24 years before the trilogy and 25 years after the prequel). A lot of the dialogue is just bad, with key slogans and catchphrases from the series repeated ad nauseam. But I loved the story, characters and special effects. Unlike the Hunger Games, there’s little hand-to-hand combat in a dusty coliseum; most of the movie takes place in an idyllic forest, where everything — from cute bunny to burbling brooks — are artificial and potentially lethal. And the huge cast of familiar characters — including Plutarch (Jesse Plemons) Effie Trinket (Elle Fanning) Drusilla Sickle (Glenn Close) and Caesar Flickerman (Kieran Culkin) are lots of fun to watch.

If you’re a hard-core Hunger Games fan, you’ll love this one, too.

Paper Tiger

Wri/Dir: James Gray

It’s the late 1980s in Queens, NY. Irwin Pearl (Miles Teller: Eternity, Whiplash, ) is an engineer who runs his own business. He’s happily married to Linda (Scarlett Johansson: Jurassic World,  Asteroid City, Marriage Story, Under the Skin ) a homemaker. They have two beloved sons, Scott and Ben (Gavin Goudey, Roman Engel) whom they send to private school to prepare them for an Ivy League future. While Irwin is into DIY improvements to the house, his older brother Uncle Gary (Adam Driver: Ferrari, White Noise, House of Gucci, Marriage Story,  The Report, Black KKKlansman, Paterson,  Hungry Hearts) is a whole different story. He’s flashy and exciting, and the boys are in awe of the pistol he sports in an ankle holster. He used to be a cop, and still knows all the moves. So when he offers Irwin the chance of a lifetime, and possibly great wealth, he’s ready to try it.

Gary has insider knowledge that the heavily polluted Gowanus canal is in line for a cleanup, and the land around it will be developed. With Irwin’s environmental engineering skills, and Gary’s savvy, they can make a killing. But when they discover their new business partners are in the Russian Mob, everything starts to unravel. And when his two sons are physically threatened by the gangsters, Irwin wants to pull out. But are they in too deep? Meanwhile Linda is in a medical crisis of her own: a simple car crash reveals a potentially dangerous condition. Should she tell her family about it when they are already facing a crisis?

Paper Tiger is a superb drama about the gives and takes of a family facing unexpected threats: who is in charge, who is to blame, and what are their motives. Adam Driver and Scarlett Johansen are both amazing in their roles. They previously co-starred in Noah Baumbach’s Marriage Story, but in this one they’re in-laws, telling their respective stories separately. James Gray only makes a movie every few years but he just gets better and better. Your opinions of the lead characters constantly shifts as secrets are revealed. Every scene is perfectly crafted,  both emotionally and aesthetically. He’s the kind of filmmaker whose visual and audio cues tie the whole movie into a perfect picture. And the level of tension sustained in this film is more frightening than most thrillers or horror movies. It grabs you and grips you and never lets go.

I strongly recommend Paper Tiger.  

Paper Tiger, Hunger Games: Sunrise of the Reaping opens this weekend while Elsinore starts on Wednesday in Toronto; check your local listings.

This is Daniel Garber at the Movies, each Saturday morning, on CIUT 89.5 FM and on my website  culturalmining.com


Discover more from Cultural Mining

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply